Added to pre-existing inflammation, mRNA-lipid nanoparticles induce inflammation exacerbation (IE)
Hamideh Parhiz, Jacob S. Brenner, Priyal N. Patel, Tyler E. Papp, Hamna Shahnawaz, Qin Li, Ruiqi Shi, Marco E. Zamora, Amir Yadegari, Oscar A. Marcos-Contreras, Ambika Natesan, Norbert Pardi, Vladimir V. Shuvaev, Raisa Kiseleva, Jacob W. Myerson, Thomas Uhler, Rachel S. Riley, Xuexiang Han, Michael DOI 10.1016/j.jconrel.2021.12.027
Summary
Nucleoside-modified mRNA lipid nanoparticle (modmRNA-LNP) technology is clinically successful, but its behavior in pre-existing inflammatory or immune-challenged conditions is poorly characterized. This gap raises the risk of adverse effects when modmRNA-LNPs are administered to patients with ongoing inflammation. IE with LPS + modmRNA-LNP: Serum IL-6 increased 14-fold vs LPS alone and 94-fold vs modmRNA-LNP in naive mice. Liver MIP-2 increased 11-fold vs LPS alone and 52-fold vs modmRNA-LNP in naive mice. Liver MIP-2 mRNA.
Keywords
Lipid nanoparticlemRNANanoparticlesLiposomesMacrophagesNanocarriersGene delivery
Purpose: Nucleoside-modified mRNA lipid nanoparticle (modmRNA-LNP) technology is clinically successful, but its behavior in pre-existing inflammatory or immune-challenged conditions is poorly characterized. This gap raises the risk of adverse effects when modmRNA-LNPs are administered to patients with ongoing inflammation.
Hypothesis: In mice with pre-existing LPS-induced inflammation, IV administration of modmRNA-LNP will exacerbate pro-inflammatory cytokine responses (inflammation exacerbation, IE) in an LNP-dependent, mRNA-cargo-independent, TLR4/macrophage-dependent, and dose/time-dependent manner, and this effect can be mitigated by anti-inflammatory drugs or by temporal/spatial separation of the inflammatory stimulus and LNP.
Aims: Induce acute inflammation in mice with LPS (IT or IV) and then administer modmRNA-LNP IV; screen for inflammatory markers such as IL-6 and MIP-2. - Determine whether IE is specific to the LNP, independent of mRNA cargo, and dependent on LNP formulation/ionizable lipid. - Investigate mechanism using TLR3 KO, TLR4 KO, and macrophage-depleted mice. - Test mitigation strategies: corticosteroids, pioglitazone, temporal separation, and spatial targeting away from liver/spleen. - Assess generalizability to non-LPS inflammatory models (intrastriatal TNF-α and IV oleic acid).
Delivery system: Platform: Nucleoside-modified mRNA lipid nanoparticle (modmRNA-LNP). - LNP composition: Ionizable cationic lipid (proprietary to Acuitas), phosphatidylcholine, cholesterol, PEG-lipid; ~80 nm diameter. - mRNA: m1Ψ-modified, purified mRNA encoding luciferase or other cargo; CpG/dsRNA contaminants removed. - Comparators: Empty-LNP; DLin-MC3-DMA-LNP; C12-200-LNP; LNP without ionizable lipid; liposomes; nanogels; AAV empty capsids. - Targeted LNPs: Anti-PECAM, anti-PLVAP, and anti-VCAM antibody-conjugated LNPs for lung or brain endothelial targeting. - Payload/dose: modmRNA-LNP at 0.032 or 0.32 mg mRNA/kg IV. - Inflammation trigger: LPS from E. coli O111:B4; IV 2 mg/kg or IT 1 mg/kg.
Approach: Mice: C57BL/6J wild-type, TLR3 KO, TLR4 KO; 6–8 weeks old. - Models: LPS-induced systemic inflammation (IV), LPS-induced acute lung inflammation (IT), intrastriatal TNF-α brain inflammation, IV oleic acid acute lung injury. - Timing: LPS at t = 0 h; modmRNA-LNP at t = 4 h unless otherwise stated; tissues harvested at t = 8 h. - Groups/controls: Naive vs LPS-treated; modmRNA-LNP vs empty-LNP vs no treatment; ± clodronate liposomes; ± dexamethasone or pioglitazone; n = 3–6 animals per group. - Doses: LPS 2 mg/kg IV or 1 mg/kg IT; modmRNA-LNP 0.32 mg mRNA/kg IV; clodronate liposomes 50 mg/kg IV; dexamethasone 2 mg/kg IP or SC.
Key methods: ELISA for IL-6 in serum and MIP-2 in liver/brain homogenates. - LEGENDplex mouse inflammation panel for cytokine screening. - qRT-PCR for MIP-2, TLR3, and TLR4 expression. - Bioluminescence imaging (IVIS) for luciferase mRNA translation in liver and spleen. - Flow cytometry for LNP uptake in lung endothelial cells, monocytes/macrophages, and other leukocytes. - Bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) analysis for leukocyte count and protein concentration.
Key results: IE with LPS + modmRNA-LNP: Serum IL-6 increased 14-fold vs LPS alone and 94-fold vs modmRNA-LNP in naive mice. Liver MIP-2 increased 11-fold vs LPS alone and 52-fold vs modmRNA-LNP in naive mice. Liver MIP-2 mRNA increased 11-fold and 8-fold, respectively. - LNP-specific and mRNA-independent: Empty-LNP caused the same IE; DLin-MC3-DMA-LNP and C12-200-LNP showed similar IE. LNP without ionizable lipid, liposomes, nanogels, and AAV empty capsids did not cause IE. - Reduced mRNA translation: LPS pretreatment reduced luciferase expression ~4-fold in liver and ~3.3-fold in spleen. - Macrophage/TLR4 dependence: LPS increased monocyte/macrophage LNP uptake from ~20% to ~60%. Clodronate depletion reduced IE 10-fold for serum IL-6 and 8-fold for liver MIP-2. TLR4 KO mice showed no IE; TLR3 KO mice behaved like WT. - Mitigation: Dexamethasone reduced IL-6 by 3.5–4-fold; pioglitazone showed partial reduction. IE was lost when modmRNA-LNP was given 24 h after LPS. Lung-targeted anti-PECAM or anti-PLVAP LNPs with systemic LPS showed significantly lower systemic IL-6 and liver MIP-2. - Other inflammatory models: No IE observed with intrastriatal TNF-α or IV oleic acid.
Interpretation: The authors claim this is the first identification of LNP-mediated inflammation exacerbation (IE) in the setting of LPS-induced inflammation. They conclude that IE is LNP-specific, independent of mRNA cargo, macrophage/TLR4-dependent, dose- and time-dependent, and can be partially alleviated by corticosteroids or by temporal/spatial separation. This has implications for using modmRNA-LNPs in patients with gram-negative bacterial inflammation, sepsis, or other TLR4-driven inflammatory states.
Limitations: IE was demonstrated only with LPS-induced inflammation; it did not generalize to TNF-α or oleic acid models. - Findings are limited to mouse models; no large-animal or human validation. - Chronic inflammatory or immune-challenged conditions were not addressed. - The modmRNA-LNP dose used was higher than typical SARS-CoV-2 vaccine doses but lower than some therapeutic mRNA antibody doses. - Mechanistic details beyond TLR4/macrophage involvement remain incompletely defined.
Related articles
Let's engineer the next delivery breakthrough together
We co-develop nanocarrier and biosensing programs with pharma, biotech and academic groups — from target selection through GMP supply.
